Anthro in the news 3/8/10

• Religion and relief aid in Haiti
BBC carried an article pointing to the low profile of voodoo in the aftermath of the earthquake. Some observers think that Christian organizations are dominating the scene and even denying benefits to Haitians who demonstrate adherence to voodoo (a blend of Christian and African beliefs and rituals) by wearing peasant clothing or a voodoo handkerchief. Although voodoo practitioners were included in the three days of prayer in February, voodoo leaders themselves have kept a low profile. Gerald Murray, professor of anthropology at the University of Florida, comments: “For a religion that’s supposedly the national religion of the Haitian people, it’s amazingly absent in the earthquake phenomena.” He points the role of theology. In the voodoo belief system, natural disasters are caused by bondye, a distant supreme being that cannot be influenced by humans. Humans can propitiate only loa, beings in charge of more everyday matters such as illness. Because the earthquake was not caused by loa, voodoo leaders are theologically framed out of the larger picture. They are, however, likely to be playing a major, if quiet, role helping people deal with the effects of the earthquake on their health and welfare.

•For her own good…
In Cameroon, and perhaps elsewhere in West and Central Africa, many mothers “iron” the emerging breasts of their young daughters in order to protect them from male sexual interests and possible pregnancy. The process varies but seems typically to involve pressing a hot stone or piece of wood onto a girl’s breasts. An article in the Washington Post quotes Flavien Ndonko, an anthropologist with the German Agency for Technical Cooperation: “It’s body mutilation and against women’s rights.” He noted that some of the consequences are abscesses, infection, deformation, lactation problems, cysts, possible links to breast cancer, and emotional stress. A survey he helped to conduct revealed that one-fourth of girls had experienced breast ironing.

• Freakanomics beware: here comes anthropology!
Robin Dunbar’s new book, How Many Friends Does One Person Need?, is reviewed in the Scotsman. Dunbar is a professor of evolutionary anthropology at Oxford University who thinks widely, poses big questions, and brings science to them. In this book he addresses such issues as how the symmetry in Barack Obama’s face helped him win the election, why women gossip and men brag, why laughter is good for you, why morning sickness is good for babies, and the social consequences of the unbalanced sex ratio in China.

• The lost have been found, again
According to oral traditions of the Lemba tribe of Zimbabwe and South Africa, their ancestors were Jews who fled the Holy Land 2,500 years ago. Many of the customs of this population of around 80,000, are exact parallels with Jewish tradition. British researchers have now established a genetic link to a common ancestor who lived about 3,000 years ago in north Arabia. This discovery confirms a longstanding argument about such a link by Tudor Parfitt, a professor in the University of London’s School of Oriental and African Studies. Parfitt has been studying the Lembas’ cultural practices and language for over a decade.

• The unregistered millions
The births of more than 45 million children worldwide are unregistered. Most of these are in South Asia and Africa. Many countries have not explained why it is important to have a birth certificate. Cultural and logistical constraints are also at play, as explained by Olungah Owuor, lecturer in anthropology at the University of Nairobi: “Birth certificates are a foreign concept to Africa, where celebrations and rituals were normally what would mark the birth of a child…The public must first be socialised to understand the importance of having the document before the Government issues ultimatums that would force people to get the certificate just for the sake of it.”

• She cooks for him
Harvard University’s Richard Wrangham, professor of human evolutionary biology, published the popular book, Catching Fire: How Cooking Made Us Human, last year. It is the subject of a new documentary from BBC Horizons. In the Sun Herald, Simon Webster quotes Wrangham’s understanding of the links among cooking, gender roles, and marriage: Marriage is a “protection racket in which a woman is required to feed a man because of the threat of having her food taken by other men.” This blogger hasn’t seen the documentary and wonders if Wrangham actually says that…if so, it raises basic questions about science and whereof one can and cannot speak.

• Read my eggshell
Lines etched into 60,000 year-old ostrich eggshells found in South Africa have the archaeologists debating whether they are evidence of the earliest art or the earliest written “language.” Excavations by archaeologist Pierre-Jean Texier of the University of Bordeaux and his colleagues have unearthed more than 270 fragments. The fragments span a period of over 5,000 years but show consistently similar designs. Long-term repetition is a hallmark of symbolic communication and modern human thinking. The eggshells were likely used as containers, and markings may have indicated the contents or the owner. Until recently, Texier says, Bushmen in the region carved geometric motifs on ostrich eggshells as a mark of ownership. Findings are published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

• The flushing gene
Around half of all people of Asian descent have a genetic trait that causes the face to redden when a person drinks alcoholic beverages. New research suggests that the genetic mutation for alcohol-induced facial flushing emerged 10,000 years ago in southern China. As quoted in Time.com, Bing Su, one of the researchers involved in the study from the China Academy of Sciences, says: “This is one of the few cases reported demonstrating the genetic adaptation of human populations to the dramatic changes in agriculture and diet in Neolithic times.” The argument is that the red-face gene evolved as an alarm system warning the person to drink less. Findings will be published in BMC Evolutionary Biology.


• More on culture shaping genes

Related to the previous discussion of the flushing gene is Nicholas Wade’s article in the New York Times on lactose tolerance as the major example of cultural change affecting genetic change. The argument that culture and genes can co-evolve has been slow to catch on in mainstream science. According to Mark Stoneking, a geneticist at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, the selective pressure of culture is relatively recent, probably dating to 10,000-20,000 years ago.

Anthro connection: beauty in Japan

Today’s Washington Post carried an article called “Big in Japan? Fat chance for nation’s young women.” Among other points, we learn that young women in Japan are slimmer than they were two decades ago. Young men, however, have become heavier.

In the United States, more than one-third of the population is categorized as “obese” on the basis of BMI (Body Mass Index). In Japan, the obese population is four percent of the total.

Media messages about thinness abound. In addition, peer pressure is strong. Japanese women are outspokenly critical of each other’s looks, according to a researcher in the Keio University School of Medicine. Thinness among young women is reaching unhealthy levels. Eating disorders are becoming more frequent.

How to gain a deeper understanding of all this? I highly recommend a book called Beauty Up: Exploring Contemporary Japanese Body Aesthetics by cultural anthropologist Laura Miller.

One chapter takes you to an aesthetic salon where various procedures on the body promise to make you beautiful. Another explores breast mania. Even though young Japanese women want to be slender, they also desire larger-than-A-cup breasts and are willing to spend a lot of money on massage, pills and other ways to increase breast size.

Another chapter explores appetite and dieting of young women. Miller comments on the recent explosion of new products to help women achieve the desire for a thin body: weight-loss services, diet goods and diet fads like the Hot Pepper Diet or the Karaoke Diet in which the dieter sings and dances to her favorite hit song at least once a day. All this in response to what Miller sees as a surge in the desire for female thinness starting around 1980.

At the same time that young, modern women are rejecting a body shape associated with fertility and nurturance, they are also rejecting marriage and motherhood. The beauty industry claims to sell young women agency and power, along with thinness. But, as Miller says, “this process rests on a mythology of transformation created by domestic and transnational corporations” (p. 206).

Photo: “Different walk of life,” creative commons licensed content by Flickr user colodio.

A heresy is occurring in Australia

Guest post by Helen Caldicott

Ever since white men appeared 200 years ago on the shores of Sydney Harbour in their uniforms, with their guns and flags, the aboriginal people have been hunted, shot at and herded off cliffs and escarpments, and have had to drink from poisoned water holes.

Until very recently, aboriginal children were stolen from their parents by policemen under the direction of government and transported to “Christian” mission stations where they were taught English history, language and morality. Many were treated as slaves and sexually and physically abused. This horrifying history leads me to the current abuse and desecration of several aboriginal tribes inhabiting their land in the Northern Territory.

This land called Muckaty Station is conveniently located adjacent to the railway line, constructed recently by Dick Cheney’s former company Halliburton, which bisects Australia connecting Darwin, a port in the north, to Adelaide a port in the south.

In its wisdom, the previous conservative Howard government allocated this site along with three others for a possible radioactive dump. At the time the opposition labor party strongly criticized the nomination of Muckaty, labeling the Howard government’s National Radioactive Waste Management Bill as sordid and draconian. At the same time, the Howard government offered $12 million to just two of the tribal elders, excluding all other members. However the new labor government under the act can still impose a nuclear waste dump on the Northern Territory against the wishes of the indigenous owners and the government of the NT.

Muckaty Station sits above an ancient aquifer which is used by both the aborigines for drinking water and white station owners to water their cattle. It also experiences large intermittent rainfalls during the year.

Not only does the government intend to bury Australia’s low and high level waste at this site, but there is a distinct possibility that waste from overseas – namely the United States – will be transported by ship and on the Halliburton line to Muckaty Station, thus making Australia one of the main radioactive waste dumps in the world.

The reason for this eventuality is that Howard signed a treaty with the American government called the Global Nuclear Energy Partnership GNEP which stipulates that after Australia exports its large quantities of uranium to nuclear powered countries, the high-level radioactive waste would be re-imported to prevent lateral proliferation of nuclear weapons. Despite its previous promises, Labor has not vetoed the GNEP and there is a suspicion that a secret deal was negotiated under the aegis of the GNEP to relieve America of some of its deadly radioactive waste.

Long-lived carcinogenic isotopes will inevitably leak into underground water systems, bio-concentrate in food chains and over generations induce cancer, genetic disease and congenital deformities in humans, animals and plants. A dismal prospect indeed for Australia’s future.

Helen Caldicott is an advocate of citizen action to remedy the nuclear and environmental crises. She has devoted the last 38 years to an international campaign to educate the public about the medical hazards of the nuclear age and the necessary changes in human behavior to stop environmental destruction. Dr. Caldicott holds a medical degree from the University of Adelaide Medical School and was on the staff of Children’s Hospital Medical Center, Boston, when she resigned to work full time on the prevention of nuclear war. While living in the United States, she co-founded the Physicians for Social Responsibility and the umbrella group, International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War which won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1985. She also founded the Women’s Action for Nuclear Disarmament. The recipient of many awards and the subject of several films, she currently divides her time between Australia and the United States.

Image: “Northern Territory.” Creative commons licensed content from Flickr user dinaiz.

Why are some wars worse for women?

Guest post by Laura Wilson

The United State Institute of Peace recently presented the second part of its program on The Other Side of Gender: Masculinity Issues in Violent Conflict. Panelists Elisabeth Wood, Professor of Political Science at Yale University, and Jocelyn Kelly, Research Coordinator with the Harvard Humanitarian Initiative, drew on their diverse experiences in conflict zones worldwide to answer the question: Why are some wars worse for women than others?

Wood compared gender-based violence (GBV) in conflict zones in Sri Lanka, El Salvador, Guatemala, and Israel/Palestine. She finds that rape is not an inevitable by-product of war. Combatants in different war-zones, on different sides of a conflict, or even within the same group take markedly different approaches to rape and violence against women. To effectively challenge rape as a tool of war, it is essential to understand why GBV is rare in some conflict zones. The fact that soldiers in some wartime situations respect human rights indicates that all combatants can and should be held accountable for their actions.

Wood argues that the cultural setting of war is the primary determinant of GBV.  She highlights the importance of institutional norms within combatant groups:  Does the military hierarchy punish, tolerate, or promote GBV?  Is GBV a war-time innovation, or does it represent a pre-war phenomenon? Is the chain of command well-managed?

Generally, GBV is less prevalent in settings where the top-down repression of GBV is high and where religious and socio-cultural norms inhibit rape as a tactic. This pattern provides insights into how to address the high rates of GBV in other contexts.

Jocelyn Kelly focused on one message: jobs.  During her interviews with Mai Mai rebels in the DRC, combatants expressed a strong desire to demobilize if provided with job opportunities and livelihoods.

The Mai Mai originally formed to protect Congolese villages and minerals from the Rwandan Interhamwe. Many young men without economic opportunities joined the rebels who make their living scavenging and stealing from local communities. Life as a rebel soldier cuts young men off from social interaction and marriage prospects. But many yearn for the chance to start a normal family life. Within this context, soldiers may rape out of bitterness or a psychological “war fog.”  While professionalizing the rebel groups, or incorporating them into the national army, might lower the risk of GBV during conflict, Kelly asserts that economic empowerment would have the greatest impact in de-militarizing the Congo and bringing combatants back into everyday life.

The presentations thus forcefully raised this question: Is the best way to prevent GBV during war to change the culture of war or improve livelihoods through development?

In his new book Tearing Apart the Land: Islam and Legitimacy in Southern Thailand, Duncan McCargo, professor of politics at the University of Leeds, provides insight with a story. Walking through a Malay village in Southern Thailand shortly after the kidnapping and murder of two marines, McCargo noticed Thai soldiers digging holes in front of each house. He learned that the soldiers were creating fish ponds in order to bring “economic empowerment” to the village to prevent further violence.

McCargo asks: would a fish pond have saved the lives of the two marines? Some (fish) food for thought.

Laura Wilson is a candidate for an M.A. degree in international development studies at The George Washington University with a focus on gender, human rights and development. She received a B.S. degree in foreign service from Georgetown University in 2007. She is currently the program assistant for the International Development Studies program.

Image: “Mother & baby wait…” from Farchana Refugee Camp in Chad, photo by Lin Piwowarczyk, from Flickr user physiciansforhumanrights, licensed with Creative Commons.

Upcoming film screening

In honor of International Women’s Day, please join us for this upcoming event at the Elliott School of International Affairs:

Poto Mitan:

Haitian Women, Pillars of the Global Economy

a film screening

a panel discussion following the film with:

Mark Schuller
Co-producer and Co-director of Poto Mitan; Assistant Professor of African American Studies and Anthropology,
City University of New York

Julie Meyer
Director, Lambi Fund

Leigh Carter
Executive Director, Fonkoze USA

Monday, March 8, 2010
6:00 pm – 8:30 pm
Reception following

1957 E Street, NW
Harry Harding Auditorium, Room 213

RSVP here

Sponsored by the Global Women’s Forum and the Culture in Global Affairs Program of the Elliott School of International Affairs, The George Washington University

Anthro in the news 3/1/10

Ethnography of sexual violence in Peru inspires award-winning documentary
Kimberly Theidon, associate professor of cultural anthropology at Harvard University, is an expert on violence in Peru and especially sexual violence against women. Her book of essays on the subject, Entre Prójimos, is the source of inspiration for the documentary, The Milk of Sorrow. It has already won the Berlin International Film Festival’s highest prize, the Golden Bear, and was nominated for Best Foreign Language Picture at this year’s Academy Awards. Theidon had no idea that her work was the basis for the film until friends started emailing her to convey their congratulations. While she was not consulted during the production of the film, she has no complaints about it and is considering a trip to Los Angeles for the Oscar party.

President Obama’s mother recognized for work in economic anthropology
Stanley Ann Dunham, President Obama’s late mother, will receive an award from Gadjah Mada University in Yogyakarta in honor of “her tireless efforts in the field of economic anthropology.” Her dissertation, recently published in the U.S., is about microfinance and small crafts businesses in central Java. The award will be presented in October at a conference called “Local Wisdom, Global Solutions” where keynote speakers are expected to be Al Gore and Muhammud Yunus.

Update on Haitians in Little Miami
An article in the Miami Herald describes the effects of Haiti’s earthquake tragedy on members of the diaspora in Little Miami. The economic downturn in the U.S. is making it extremely difficult to send money to family members in Haiti, and so they have to respond to phone calls from Haiti asking for help by replying that they have little to offer.  Members of the Haitian diaspora also have to deal with the grief caused by the deaths and injuries of loved ones.  Many also face the daily worry of being undocumented. The question of how many Haitians lives in the U.S. is difficult to answer because so many lack documentation, and they don’t show up in census counts. Cultural anthropologist Bryan Page, chair of the anthropology department at the University of Miami, says: “If you have a really dodgy immigration status, you’re not going to be very receptive to people showing up with their clipboards and asking questions.”

Forensic anthropology in Haiti
The U.S. is deploying multidisciplinary teams to Haiti to identify the 100 or more Americans who died in the earthquake. The American teams are called DMORTs: Disaster Mortuary Operational Response Teams. Forensic anthropologist Dana Kollman, professor at Towson University, will be studying bones excavated from the ruins along with other team members at a portable morgue at the Port-au-Prince airport.

Forensic anthropology in Guatemala
Nearly a quarter of a million people, mostly Maya Indians, disappeared during the 36-year civil war in Guatemala. In the latest attempt to identify victims, the exhumation of  a burial site with perhaps 899 bodies has been launched. It may take a year for the DNA testings to be completed.

Continue reading “Anthro in the news 3/1/10”

Preventing cervical cancer in Appalachia

In the United States, cases of invasive cervical cancer have declined in recent decades due to earlier detection through the Pap smear and improved forms of treatment. Significant regional variations exist across the country in mortality rates from cervical cancer, and the Appalachian region stands out as having high rates. It is also an area characterized by poverty, lack of transportation, and low rates of health insurance.

Faith Moves Mountains (FMM) is a health care project supported by the National Cancer Institute which seeks to reduce cervical cancer mortality in southeastern Kentucky. FMM targeted women aged 40-64 years, an age when women in the region typically stop getting Pap smears. The program followed a community-based participatory approach that is implemented through churches. Its aim is to increase cancer screening (Pap tests) through educational programming and health counseling. FMM was initiated by a team of medical faculty at the University of Kentucky.

Since many of the factors that serve as barriers to cervical cancer prevention cannot be changed, FMM took an “assets approach.” In Appalachia, two major assets are churches and social networking. The researchers arranged dates for educational workshops through churches. In order to forge links between the local people and medical care providers, they implemented a lay health advisor (LHA) program which involved local women as peer advisors. So far, the program has recruited 421 women who were rarely or never screened. While this number may not seem impressive to readers, given the logistical difficulties of working in Appalachia and the relatively sparse population, it is actually substantial.

Along the way, the researchers learned valuable lessons about how to work with the culture rather than in an outsider-driven way. For example, invitations mailed to churches asking them to participate were “returned to sender” or left unopened on the preacher’s desk. So, the researchers learned that they had to do door-to-door visits and build relationships. Also, taking notes on a laptop computer had to be abandoned as it distanced the researchers from the participants.

Image: “Blue house,” from Flickr user dok1, licensed with Creative Commons.

Mountains of a different kind

Tracy Kidder‘s widely read documentary book about Paul Farmer’s work in Haiti is called Mountains beyond Mountains. The title comes from a Haitian proverb which is translated into English as: “Beyond the mountains, more mountains.” In other words, every challenge is followed by another.

Have you by any chance read Rose George‘s book, The Big Necessity: The Unmentionable World of Human Waste and Why It Matters? If not, I highly recommend it. It will take you where no book (that I know of) has gone before. It’s about human excrement.

In following the excrement, George will guide you through the sewers of London to open defecation in rural India to the biogas revolution in villages of China: all places and situations that are quite “normal.”

Perhaps, in an updated edition, she will add a chapter on the “big necessity” in crisis situations. What happens, for example, when over a million people are displaced from their residences and are forced to survive in “tent camps?”

One things that happens is mountains beyond mountains of excrement. An article in the New York Times points to the sanitation situation and its implications for disease. Not to mention everyday misery and degradation.

The article, however, provides a ray of hope. Viva Rio, a Brazilian nongovernmental group, has launched an operation in one slum area of Port-au-Prince that turns human excrement into biogas that can be used for cooking and electricity.

This project should be replicated throughout the camps, throughout the island: turn the mountains beyond mountains of excrement into something people can use. Thank you, Viva Rio.

Image: Creative commons licensed Flickr content by BBC World Service. Feb. 9, 2010. From Haiti. “There aren’t many latrines, so this is pretty much the only way to dispose of all types of waste – dig a big hole and stick it in the ground.”

Dissenter’s account of the US Human Terrain System from the inside

Having lost his job as a Cultural Resource Management archaeologist working with the Klamath Indians, John Allison posted his cv online and was shortly contacted by the Human Terrain Systems. John had done his doctoral fieldwork in Afghanistan in 1969-70, making him a potential asset for the HTS. He listened to the HTS message that its approach will save Afghan lives and, although skeptical of the claims, decided to join up. Over the several weeks of training, his skepticism grew and, along with another skeptic, he began to raise hard questions in training sessions. He increasingly realized that HTS claims, such as building rapport with local people, were empty rhetoric that could never be achieved in the field.

Throughout several months of training before resigning, Allison corresponded by email with David Price, professor of anthropology at St. Martin’s University and a member of the Network of Concerned Anthropologists. Price details their interchange in an article in CounterPunch.

John Allison submitted a critique of the HTS upon his resignation, and it is included in Price’s article. The overarching message is that the HTS fundamentally does not address key issues of anthropological ethics, notably the guideline about avoiding any possible harm to people in the field who provide information about themselves and others. Allison stood out from others in his group because his primary goal was to save Afghan lives. The HTS is about saving American soldiers’ lives. Period.

Image: “Afghanistan bazaar,” from flickr user The US Army, licensed with Creative Commons.

Event this week at the Elliott School

The Culture in Global Affairs program is hosting its second event of 2010 this week on Wednesday, February 24.  For those in the D.C. area, we would love to have you join us. You can RSVP here.

Conflicts in Israeli Feminism and the Question of Palestine
Dr. Smadar Lavie
Associate Professor of Studies in Women and Gender
University of Virginia

February 24, 2010
6:30 – 8:00 p.m.
1957 E Street NW, Lindner Family Commons (Room 602)
RSVP Here

Professor Lavie explores the conflicts inside the Israeli feminist movements. What is largely known outside Israel, and in English, as “Israeli feminism” is the feminism of the minority European-Jewish elite. It bears little or no appeal to the grassroots – the Mizrahi (“eastern,” Hebrew) majority of Israeli women, who are of Middle Eastern origins. Most Mizrahi communities vote for right-wing parties partially because left-wing parties are associated with the Ashkenazi elite. The deep commitment of the general Mizrahi population to Zionist ideology places Mizrahi feminists, critical of Ashkenazi Zionism, in a predicament.