Anthro in the news 12/5/11

• David Graeber, the Occupy movement, and debt
An article in the New Yorker magazine called “Pre-Occupied: The origins and future of Wall Street,” focuses on the Zucotti Park occupation in Manhattan. It mentions the formative role of anarchist anthropologist David Graeber and notes his communications with Berkeley activist, Micah White. White recently nominated his entry on Wikipedia for deletion on the grounds that he is “non-notable.” The Guardian (London) carried a review article called “Books for Giving: Economics”. One of the books reviewed is Graeber’s monumental study called Debt: The First 5,000 Years. The reviewer says that is has become “one of the year’s most influential books.”

• Drug wars in Mexico threaten potters’ art and livelihood
The Dallas News carried an article about the loss of pottery sales and traditions in Chihuahua, Mexico, due to drug-related violence. It focuses on the small village of Mata Ortiz, located 150 miles from the U.S. border. It is home to some of the most prominent potters in the world. But the drug wars have driven the tourists away. The article mentions anthropologist Spencer MacCallum who has studied and written about the potters of the village. He says that the consequences for the potters are “devastating.” He notes: “With no demand for their pottery and nobody coming, I hate to see fine artists working on the road-building up in the sierra.”

• Pop-up shopping in London
Sean Carey, our contributing blogger, published a piece in the New Statesman on what is reputedly the first pop-up shopping mall. With his usual, on-the-ground lively reporting, Sean takes us to Boxpark: “It’s midday, and I am walking along Shoreditch High Street headed towards the northern end of Brick Lane. I turn into Bethnal Green Road. There is a lot of activity going on — lots of young people of various nationalities purposefully moving stuff around while others stand back and survey the results of their endeavours. I wonder what’s happening as this is normally a dead area — except on evenings at weekends, when the affluent young people of London and their counterparts from overseas come out to play and move between the various bars, clubs and restaurants in Greater Shoreditch.” There’s more, and it’s interesting, so read on.

• Take that anthro degree and…MA grad in anthropology is a documentary film-maker
Life and its various forms have always fascinated Rajive McMullen, an Indo-Canadian research scholar at the Punjab University, India. McMullen earned BA and MA degrees in anthropology from the University of Toronto. After 15 years away, he returned to India and made an anthropological documentary called The Lover and the Beloved: A Journey into Tantra, released earlier this month. The film portrays tantriks, aghoris and other holy seekers of northern India who call themselves the disciples of Guru Gorakhnath, believed to be an incarnation of Lord Shiva. The film offers a dramatic insight into tantriks’ ideas about the life cycle, especially about death. Express India quotes McMullen as saying, “It is a realistic attempt to understand both the practice and the illusive theory behind Indian Tantrism, and is intended to challenge widespread Western misinterpretations of this stream of thought.”

• Take that anthro degree and…sports/anthropology major now co-founder of Afrikids Ghana
The Daily Telegraph (London) ran a long article about AfriKids, and NGO that works in Ghana to prevent the infanticide of physically deformed infants, child labor, homelessness, and human trafficking. One of the organization’s co-founders is Georgie Feinberg, who lives in Buckinghamshire. During part of her gap year, at the age of 18, she went to Accra and volunteered in a children’s home. She returned to England and earned a BA in sports and anthropology at Oxford Brookes University. She also raised L30,000 for the children’s home. She returned to Ghana, and from then on became a driving force in creating AfriKids Ghana.

Continue reading “Anthro in the news 12/5/11”

India’s consumer society might have to wait

By contributor Sean Carey

Last week it looked like U.S. and European supermarket chains like Wal-Mart, Tesco and Carrefour would soon be allowed to enter the $396 billion retail market in India. The fast-growing country, Asia’s third-largest economy after China and Japan, has a population of 1.2 billion, which makes it the world’s second most populous nation.

The Indian retail market is expanding at an unprecedented rate and is expected to more than double in size to $796 billion (£514 billion) by 2015 as Western-style consumerism gains momentum.

Street vendor selling vegetables in Delhi. Flickr/A Culinary (Photo) Journal

The current market is largely controlled by a small family-owned stores, street vendors and hawkers. But under ever-increasing political pressure as economic growth slows, the Indian Government led by Cambridge-educated economist Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, hoped that opening up the retail market to competition would reduce food price inflation as well as indicate that the country welcomed more foreign direct investment.

The Indian Government’s decision, which did not require parliamentary approval, signalled that it would not be a free ride for foreign companies. In return for a 51 percent stake in “multi-brand retailers” and 100 percent ownership of “single-brand stores” like Nike they would be expected to contribute to the country’s infrastructure, and source at least 30 percent of supplies from small and medium-sized Indian companies. Another condition highlighted in the proposal was that foreign companies would only be able to open stores in cities of more than 1 million people that have an “organised retail sector.”

U.K. retail giant Tesco said the announcement was good news but that it was awaiting “further details on any conditions” before making any move.

Concerns about the impact of the initiative on the traditional retail system were quick to appear, however. An editorial in the Financial Times said: “A consolidated retail sector would require consolidated agriculture to supply it. Such changes could cost millions of Indians their livelihoods. With no functioning welfare system that is a serious worry.”

On Monday, two coalition allies of the Congress Party, which governs with a slender parliamentary majority, announced that they could not back the proposed change in policy towards the retail sector. One ally, M. Karunanidhi, leader of the Dravida Munnettra Kazhagam party in the southern state of Tamil Nadu said: “It is dangerous to allow foreign direct investment in retail trade as it will affect hundreds of thousands of small traders as well as the poor and middle-class consumers. It will also be a cause for economic decline for our country.”

On the same day, hundreds protested at the prospect of international retail giants arriving in their country outside a Carrefour wholesale outlet in the northern city of Jaipur.

On Tuesday, after Parliament was adjourned for the third day as the BJP opposition and its allies demanded that the initiative should be abandoned, the Prime Minister used the platform of the Youth Congress party convention in New Delhi to defend his plans. “We have not taken this decision in haste, but after a lot of consideration,” he said. “It is our firm conviction that the decision will benefit the country.”

The Hindu reported that the Prime Minister has offered an olive branch to state governments. “State governments that are not convinced of its usefulness have the means to prevent foreign participation in retail businesses in their States,” he declared.

Commentators think that the most likely option is that the Prime Minister will refer the initiative to a ministerial committee, “a traditional way of Congress kicking problems into the grass.”

The Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce and Industry has announced a nationwide strike on Thursday to protest against the proposed changes in the retail sector.

The lesson? It is surely that in the world’s largest democracy it is not a good idea to force through measures which have not been debated and do not command popular support. This is a pity since some reform of the retail market in India is urgently needed as it is estimated that around 40 percent of food and vegetable rots before coming to market.

Anthro connection: cultural heritage and development in the Middle East and North Africa

An article in Nature discusses the potential of archaeological heritage sites in Egypt and Libya for contributing to post-Arab Spring stability. For those who want more information on archaeological heritage sites in the Middle East and North Africa, cultural anthropologist Michael Cernea provides an excellent overview in his report, Cultural Heritage and Development: A Framework for Action in the Middle East and North Africa.

In addition to Cernea’s excellent recommendations, I would add a plea that any and all heritage projects in the MENA region, and elsewhere, pay special attention to participatory approaches and, particularly, inclusion of women in leadership and income-generating positions.

Anthro in the news 11/28/11

• Forensic anthropologists testify in child murder trial in Scotland
BBC News reported on a trial in Scotland involving testimony from two forensic anthropologists: Sue Black, a professor of human anatomy and forensic anthropology at Dundee University and Dr. Cunningham, a lecturer in anthropology at Dundee University. Both worked on a report which was presented in court.

• Forensic anthropologists working on murder cases in Texas
Dr. Jennifer Love is forensic anthropology director of the identification unit at the Harris County Medical Examiners Office. She and other forensic anthropologists are looking into several murder cases from as far back in 1981.

• First international student at Sikkim University
The Telegraph (India) reported on Sikkim University’s first foreign student. Tatsuki Shirai from Japan joined Sikkim Government College last year to study sociology and the Eastern Himalayas. The student came to Sikkim on a scholarship from the Hitosubashi University in Tokyo. He will return to Hitosubashi University next year to complete his undergraduate program in sociology and cultural anthropology.

• Arab spring of archaeology in Egypt?
Nature carried an article about the politics of doing archaeology in Egypt under the reign of Zawi Hawass. According to the article, “Many archaeologists working in Egypt are reluctant to speak about Hawass on the record out of fear that he could regain influence in the country. But in private, several researchers say that Hawass was intolerant of opposition and blocked excavation permits to those who published results or theories that clashed with his own.” Megan Rowland of the University of Cambridge, who recently completed a master’s degree on the political significance of Egypt’s antiquities during the revolution, is quoted as saying that “researchers who crossed Hawass became targets of intense criticism or had their permits revoked.”

• DNA sheds light on ancient “twin” burial
Two infants buried together nearly a thousand years ago in a single grave found at what is now the Angel Mounds State Historic Site in Indiana have long been thought to be twins. Scientists using an automated DNA sequencing system at the Indiana Molecular Biology Institute at Indiana University-Bloomington have learned that they were not biologically related. Charla Marshall, adjunct professor of anthropology at Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis, led the team of researchers. Marshall and three co-authors report their findings in the American Journal of Physical Anthropology.

• Ancient tuna fishing
The New Scientists reports on findings that deep sea tuna fishing occurred 42,000 years ago in island southeast Asia. Sue O’Connor at the Australian National University in Canberra and colleagues found evidence in deposits at the Jerimalai shelter on Timor-Leste, including 38,000 fish bones from 23 different taxa, including tuna and parrotfish that are found only in deep water. ABC Australia carried an interview with some of the researchers about fish hooks found at the site.

• Software to help locate fossils
According to a piece in Science Daily, Glenn Conroy, professor of  physical anthropology and colleagues at Western Michigan University, have developed a software model that mimics the workings of the human brain. So far it has proved productive in pinpointing fossil sites in the Great Divide Basin, a 4,000-square-mile stretch of rocky desert in Wyoming

• In memoriam
Allen R. Maxwell, professor emeritus of anthropology at the University of Alabama, died November 16, 2011, at the age of 71 years. He retired from the University of Alabama in 2010 after 36 years of service to the department of anthropology. Maxwell was recognized for raising the national academic profile of the department, beginning with a major revision of the anthropology curriculum when he joined the faculty in 1974. Maxwell published more than 80 scholarly articles or book chapters and gave 68 major conference presentations. His work as an ethnographer and linguist centered on the peoples of Borneo, especially Brunei and Sarawak. He enjoyed an international reputation for the depth of his understanding of Borneo’s many cultures.

Call for papers

Life and Death: A Conversation

When: May 10-13, 2012
Where: Providence Biltmore Hotel, Providence, RI
Deadline for submissions: January 15, 2012

At the 2012 Society for Cultural Anthropology Conference we encourage discussion about matters of life and death, as perceived through anthropological and ethnographic inquiry. We explicitly call for conversations in the spirit of exchange and engagement rather than isolated analysis, and encourage participants to experiment with format and topic, cross boundaries and seek unexpected connections.

Our conference invites papers, films, photo essays, and multimedia installations that track, propose, or otherwise reveal and interrogate issues related to existence, nonexistence and relatedness in a manner that invites conversation. We are as interested in topics ‘traditional’ to anthropology (rites of passage or remembrance for example) as we are in thematic newcomers and related topics — such as biopolitics — that now fill the disciplinary horizon. Multi-disciplinary presentations and contributions by non-anthropologists are likewise welcome.

See website for more information or submit a proposal.

Call for nominations: R.L. Shep Ethnic Textile Book Award

Deadline: March 1, 2012

The Textile Society of America is pleased to solicit nominations for the R. L. Shep Ethnic Textile Book Award for books published in 2011. Given annually, the award is meant to encourage the study and understanding of ethnic textile traditions by recognizing exceptional scholarship in the field. The award consists of a cash prize, funded by an endowment established by R. L. Shep in 2000. The Textile Society of America administers the endowment through an independent committee appointed by the Board of Directors. Current TSA Board members are ineligible to apply.

For further information, visit the website.

This land is your mine or…is this land my land?

Source: The Canadian Press, Nov 11, 2011:

Canada’s Tsilhqot’in Nation is going to court to block Taseko Mines Ltd. from doing preparatory work on its controversial New Prosperity mine in British Columbia’s Cariboo region.

In a petition filed with the B.C. Supreme Court, the First Nations group is asking the court to halt drilling, excavation, timber clearing, road construction and the like while reviewing provincial approvals for the work on a revised mine plan.

Chief Joe Alphonse, tribal chairman of the Tsilhqot’in National Government, said the decision affects the group’s rights and culture: “The province refused to acknowledge these impacts, no matter what we say; it is more concerned with handing over approvals,” Alphonse said in a statement. “We’ve gone to court before, we’ve stood in front of the federal panel, we have proven over and over again how important these lands are to our people and our culture — but the province never seems to get the message.”

Several First Nations oppose the project because the mine proposal would mean the destruction of a lake considered culturally significant to them.

Take a look at the mining company’s positive view of a copper mine.

Anthro in the news 11/21/11

• Understanding Afghanistan: how and for whom
The New York Times book review Sunday section carried a two-page review, with a color illustration, of three books on Afghanistan — two of them by cultural anthropologists: Noah Coburn’s Bazaar Politics, “the first extended study of an Afghan community to appear since the Taliban fell” and Thomas Barfield‘s “ambitious history.” The reviewer mentions the U.S. military’s demand for “local knowledge” and how American anthropologists are resistant to providing it. Nonetheless, cultural anthropologists’ expert knowledge of aspects of Afghanistan’s social life could help in ways not directly related to military activities. [Blogger’s note: stay tuned for another important book coming out in January 2012 co-authored by cultural anthropologist Magnus Marsden and historian Ben Hopkins].

• Impact: reducing poverty’s health burden through primary health care
Paul Farmer, physician and medical anthropologist, is a co-founder of Partners in Health and chair of the Department of Global Health and Social Medicine at Harvard Medical School. Farmer is one of the most prominently mentioned anthropologists in the mainstream media. In an op-ed this past week on sustainable health programs for the world’s poor, he writes: “Partners in Health, a nonprofit I’ve worked with for almost three decades, started by moving resources and primary care into a part of central Haiti where almost none existed. As TB, AIDS, cancer and other diseases emerged as leading killers, we did our best to combat them: Treating patients no matter the cause of the illness nor the cost of the remedy is what health-care workers are trained to do. Some of our AIDS and TB treatment efforts in rural Haiti and elsewhere achieved success rates rivaling those in hospitals in Boston. We witnessed another benefit: Delivering care for cancer, AIDS or multidrug-resistant TB improved a community’s general health. Fewer women died in childbirth, and infant mortality declined.”

• Advanced capitalism gets a look
AW’s contributor, Sean Carey of Roehampton University, published an article in the New Statesmen in which he offers insights into the worldwide demonstrations against bankers and capitalism in the world’s big economies: “Until recently, the world’s advanced economies had experienced nearly two decades of the biggest increase in prosperity in the history of mankind. This has been very fortunate for the majority of the population, especially those in the middle classes and above. As British anthropologist, Ernest Gellner, pointed out it in his acclaimed 1997 book, Nationalism, the material improvement in (most) people’s lives creates political and social legitimacy.” He goes on from there.

• Drug use in Manipur
A one-day seminar on the Impact of Drug Use in Manipur was jointly organized by the Department of Anthropology of Manipur University, India, and Community Network for Empowerment (CoNE). Speaking on the Social and Economic Impact of Drug Use in Manipur, M. C. Arun, a professor in MU’s dept of anthropology, said that the problems faced by the youth need to be addressed.

• American Anthropological Association considers ethics code revision
The Chronicle for Higher Education covered changes in the proposed new code with a focus on the “prime directive.” The previous code told anthropologists that they “have primary ethical obligations to the people, species, and materials they study and to the people with whom they work.” This means that an anthropologist’s obligation to the research population must override the goal of acquiring new knowledge. The proposed newer version has not yet been formally adopted. It explains that the primary ethical obligation is “to avoid doing harm to the lives, communities, or environments” that anthropologists study. “Dealing with ethics codes is complicated,” said cultural anthropologist David Price, a member of the committee charged with revising the guidelines and professor at Saint Martin’s University, in Washington. The word was echoed last week by fellow committee members at a panel on ethics at the annual meeting of AAA.

Continue reading “Anthro in the news 11/21/11”

A different kind of cooking show

For those of you (including me) who enjoy watching TV cooking contests, we know that the worst that can happen is that an aspiring winner is perspiring, or the presentation was chaotic, or the judges made nasty comments about the taste of one of the dishes.

For millions of women who cook family meals, especially in developing countries, the challenges are quite different. There is no panel of judges and no “time’s up” called out to arrest the work of the contestants in their well-equipped stainless-steely kitchen.

Rob Bailis speaks at the Elliott School of International Affairs, Nov 3, 2011.

Instead, there is a “killer in the kitchen” which calls time’s up for mothers and children who spend a lot of time inhaling cook stove fumes.

On November 3, Rob Bailis, assistant professor of environmental social science in the department of Forestry and Environmental Studies at Yale University, gave a CIGA seminar entitled, “Arresting the Killer in the Kitchen: The Promises and Pitfalls of Commercializing Improved Cookstoves.”

Bailis took the audience on a rich and insightful tour of how improved cook stoves could have a major positive impact on women, children, and the environment. His talk drew on knowledge about the effects of various types of fuel for daily cooking on the cooks and the wider environment.

His slides included maps of types of household fuel in various regions of the world. He brought together data from the fields of environmental studies, public health, and local surveys.

He discussed the “energy ladder hypothesis” which says that as people get wealthier, they use cleaner fuels. As I was listening, I was thinking: okay, this doesn’t sound good for the earth, given the way the economy is going.

Another point to share is this: Bailis said that Western development experts have been pushing improved cook stoves for three decades but there is very little evidence about their effectiveness in terms of reducing health risks for cooks/children and reducing deforestation and other environmental problems.

China is the country to watch on improved cook stoves. Of the 200 million improved cook stoves in the world, 80 percent are in China. Let’s hear about the “best practices” there and how they might be replicated elsewhere.

Thirty years is a long time, especially without much to say in terms of what works. Time to switch channels and get back to the cooking throw-down.

Maybe we need a TV show about what works in development?

Update from Professor Rob Bailis:
In fact, there is evidence that some improved stoves certainly improve quality and, based on that, we can justifiably hypothesize that if families adopt such stoves and use them regularly, then their air quality will improve and their health risk will be reduced. More importantly, there is evidence of this – just last week (about a week after my presentation) a paper was published in the Lancet by Kirk Smith and his team. This reports the results of the first randomized control trial based on improved cookstove adoption. They found that the stoves they promoted reduced the incidence of severe forms of respiratory infection by around 30%. So the evidence exists. What is lacking is program-specific follow-up to understand whether a given intervention is resulting in effective and long-term stove adoption. But, like I hinted at in my talk, the carbon markets are having an interesting influence on project monitoring by creating elaborate protocols to make sure stoves are actually used.

Post-doctoral research associate position at UMD

Position: The department of Anthropology, University of Maryland, anticipates hiring a two-year post-doctoral fellow for August 2012. It is expected that extramural support will be developed, either singly or in collaboration with current faculty and staff. Candidates must demonstrate an active research agenda with publications, field experience, and teaching excellence.

Qualifications: Qualifications include a recently awarded doctoral degree in anthropology with specialization in diaspora theory and demonstrated potentially innovative research capability.

How to apply: Visit the UMD jobs website for a full posting.